New & Current Releases
Archives: A-Z By Title
Archives: A-Z By Author
Advanced Search

All-Time High Scores
Best Of 2006
Best Of 2005
Best Of 2004
How Metascores Are Calculated
Discuss Books In Our Forums

Stars indicate the most critically-acclaimed books.

The Sunday Philosophy Club
An Isabel Dalhousie Mystery
by Alexander McCall Smith


4.4

based on 12 reviews
read critic reviews
how did we calculate this?

based on 5 votes
read user comments
rate this book

Compare prices at pricegrabber.com

Buy it at powells.com

Buy it at amazon.com

Buy it at amazon.co.uk

The first in a series. Isabel Dalhousie witnesses a man's fatal fall from a balcony. Since she is the last person he saw before his death, she feels she owes it to him to investigate.

Pantheon, 256 pages
09/28/2004
$19.95

ISBN: 0375422986

Fiction
Mystery & Thrillers

All reviews are classified as one of five grades: Outstanding (4 points), Favorable (3), Mixed (2), Unfavorable (1) and Terrible (0). To calculate the Metascore, we divide total points achieved by the total points possible (i.e., 4 x the number of reviews), with the resulting percentage (multiplied by 100) being the Metascore. Learn more...

Chicago Sun-Times Henry Kisor

If you loved Precious Ramotswe, you'll take Isabel Dalhousie to your heart this fall.

Daily Telegraph Anthony Daniels

McCall Smith has the gift of evoking an entire social atmosphere in very few and simple words. Edinburgh had better brace itself for more of his gentle satire and social commentary.

Entertainment Weekly Jennifer Reese

Opportunities to read about an intelligent, inquisitive woman trying to lead a meaningful, moral life crop up so infrequently that the mild-mannered, loosely constructed Philosophy Club glows like a rare jewel. [1 Oct. 2004, p. 76]

Houston Chronicle Jeanne A. LeBlanc

Smith has once again succeeded brilliantly in constructing not only believable and engaging characters but also a vivid and particular sense of place.

Kirkus Reviews

This new series, which makes Edinburgh feel as intimate as Mma Ramotswe's Gaborone, just might fill the bill for patient, literate readers mourning the death of Amanda Cross.

San Francisco Chronicle Allison Block

McCall Smith's assessments of fellow humans are piercing and profound.

The Globe And Mail [Toronto] Bill Richardson

Writing is an act of leading, and reading demonstrates a willingness to be led -- Alexander McCall Smith's gift, one of them, is to inspire an eagerness to follow. [9 Oct. 2004, D4]

The New York Times Janet Maslin

This book is a clear demonstration of Mr. McCall Smith's own philosophy: that there is wisdom in inviting readers into a world of kindness, gentility and creature comforts. Offer the literary equivalent of herbal tea and a cozy fire. They'll come back for more.

The New York Times Book Review Marilyn Stasio

Isabel's search for truth (and a moral solution to murder) follows a route that offers tantalizing glimpses of Edinburgh's complex character and a nice, long look into the beautiful mind of a thinking woman.

USA Today Deirdre Donahue

The Sunday Philosophy Club captures the cold, foggy, history-drenched atmosphere of Edinburgh as effectively as McCall's African series conveys that continent's heat and landscape.

The Spectator Antonia Fraser

The picture of genteel Edinburgh, where an art exhibition is the local version of a rave-up, is amusing enough, even if the unregenerate like me may find themselves longing for the rougher Edinburgh world of Ian Rankin's Inspector Rebus. The trouble is that Isabel Dalhousie herself is not very amusing, or, to put it more bluntly, charm was left out of the equation of her character.

Library Journal Nicole A. Cook

Unfortunately, Smith's subplots are more interesting than the main mystery, and Isabel tends to get bogged down in philosophical digressions, but the writing and characters propel the narrative forward.

The average user rating for this book is 4.4 (out of 10) based on 5 User Votes
Note: User votes are NOT included in the Metascore calculation.

Jo D gave it a3:
Have enjoyed Ladies Detective Agency series, but was very disappointed with this one. Could have done with a good edit to get rid of much of repetitive - "I am now going to teach you - poor idiot reader - about ethics" - stuff. Just write about ethics - don't treat us like imbeciles, Mr Smith !

Janet T gave it an8:
more to this book than meets the eye, great subtlety, an enjoyable read

Siobhan L gave it a3:
Tedious and precious.

Sheila Y gave it a4:
Kept expecting more to happen. Isabel is boring.

Terry M gave it a4:
Sub par. So sub par. Such a disappointment.

Discuss this book in our forums

Return to top of page

The Sunday Philosophy Club An Isabel Dalhousie Mystery by Alexander McCall Smith

The Sunday Philosophy Club
An Isabel Dalhousie Mystery
by Alexander McCall Smith